The story mode has been updated, with team management for a longer period of time. In the Superstar mode, a rookie player can be created or imported from NCAA Football 09, aiming to improve skills and become one of the best players. The game also features an analysis tool to inspect tactics and mistakes.
The gameplay includes various options such as one-button gameplay, handicapping, and adaptive skill levels for new players. A Virtual Trainer is introduced, where twelve drills can be done in a holographic environment. The game also has updated graphics, player roster, and features like Grudge Match and Slide Protection.